May 15, 2024| Odds Shark

We’re into the second round of the Stanley Cup playoffs now. Every day of the NHL postseason, Michel Anderson and myself, have you set with daily expert picks.

Read all of our picks or jump ahead to the game you’re most interested in: 


NHL Playoffs Betting Picks

Visit our NHL betting hub daily for expert analysis for every series and playoff betting tips to find an edge for every bet.

Rolling Records
Michel: 38-21 (+7.25 Units)
Josie: 25-31 (-4.00 Units)

Game 5: avalanche vs stars preview & pick
The Game:
Colorado Avalanche vs Dallas Stars, 8 PM ET

Team Puckline Total Moneyline
Colorado Avalanche +1.5 (-205) O6.5 (+102) +124
Dallas Stars -1.5 (+170) U6.5 (-122) -148


Josie’s Take: Colorado has spiraled out of control quickly. The Avs, which scored 28 goals in the first round, have managed to scoop up just a goal in each of their last two outings.

The offense I once thought would carry the team to a cup run has disappeared. Nichushkin’s, who had at least one goal in seven of his eight playoff appearances, suspension is a distraction and massive loss. 

Meanwhile, everything is getting brighter for the Stars, who’ve outscored the Avs 14-5 in the last three games. Jake Oettinger, the Conn Smythe favorite, is playing top notch hockey. The 25-year-old has recorded over a .960SV% in his last two starts. Following a road win, Dallas has won eight-straight games. Plus, they’ve covered the puckline in four of its last five meetings with Colorado.

While the Avalanche crumbles, the Stars will shine and advance on into the next round. 

Pick: Stars -1.5 (+170)